What is the primary responsibility of a debate judge?

The primary responsibility of a debate judge is to evaluate arguments and effectiveness to determine the winner. This entails assessing the quality of the arguments presented by both sides, analyzing their structure, clarity, and relevance, as well as the debaters' delivery and overall persuasiveness. A judge must remain neutral and focus on which side more effectively persuades the audience through logical reasoning and evidence.

While providing feedback and ensuring that rules are followed are important aspects of a judge's role, they are secondary to the main function of determining the outcome based on the comparative strength of the arguments. Active participation in the debate goes against the impartial role a judge must maintain, as their duty is to observe and judge rather than engage in the discussion themselves.